Can Employers Ask About Lack of Canadian Experience?

For newcomers to Canada, seeking employment that matches their skills and expertise can be a challenging journey. A frequently encountered obstacle is the requirement for Canadian work experience. While this criterion may seem reasonable, it raises questions about discrimination and legality. In this article, we will explore whether it is illegal for employers to inquire about a candidate’s lack of Canadian work experience and shed light on employment rights in Canada.

Barriers Faced by Newcomers

The pursuit of meaningful work for newcomers often reveals various barriers. The Ontario Human Rights Commission identifies challenges such as employers not recognizing foreign credentials, language difficulties, lack of job-related learning opportunities, and even outright discrimination. One particular barrier is the demand for “Canadian experience,” a requirement that has sparked discussions about fairness and inclusivity.

Legal Implications and Human Rights Act

According to the Canadian Human Rights Act, federal-sector employers are prohibited from asking candidates about characteristics like age, gender, race, religion, and more. While most employers fall under provincial jurisdiction, provincial laws usually align with the Canadian Human Rights Act. It’s important to note that questions about the “Canadian experience” may be deemed discriminatory unless such experience is a genuine occupational necessity.

Discrimination and “Canadian Experience”

Requiring “Canadian experience” can potentially lead to discrimination based on factors like race, ancestry, and ethnicity. The Ontario Human Rights Commission’s guide titled “Removing the ‘Canadian Experience’ Barrier” emphasizes that demanding Canadian work experience could violate the Ontario Human Rights Code. The guide provides insights on establishing legitimate job requirements and offers best practices for employers and regulatory bodies.

Permissible Inquiries by Employers

Employers have the right to inquire about qualifications that are pertinent to the job role. For instance, if a position requires a driver’s license, the employer can ask if the candidate possesses one. Additionally, employers can inquire about criminal convictions and may request a police record check. However, an employer is not allowed to directly ask about a candidate’s Canadian work experience.

Understanding Employment Rights in Canada

Canada places great importance on workers’ rights, including those of foreign workers. Anti-discrimination laws are in place to ensure equal treatment in the workplace. The Canadian Human Rights Act strictly prohibits discrimination based on various grounds, extending these protections to permanent residents and individuals working in Canada on visas.

Legal vs. Practical Concerns

While inquiring about Canadian work experience is not technically illegal, it raises ethical and practical concerns. Discrimination, even if unintentional, can exclude qualified candidates and hinder diversity in the workforce. Moreover, this criterion may not accurately reflect a candidate’s abilities or potential contributions to the company.

Promoting Inclusivity and Fair Hiring Practices

To create an inclusive and diverse workforce, employers are encouraged to evaluate candidates based on their skills, qualifications, and potential. Employers can consider alternative questions that focus on a candidate’s ability to perform the job effectively. Asking about legal authorization to work in Canada is appropriate, but probing about Canadian experience may deter skilled newcomers from applying.

Get help with your immigration today!